Bonnie Tyler – “It’s a Heartache” Lyrics Meaning

Bonnie Tyler’s “It’s a Heartache” isn’t just your ordinary breakup song. It delves deep into the pain of loving someone deeply, only to be disappointed. The song discusses the cruel timing of heartbreak and the comparison of profound love against the agony it can sometimes cause. This isn’t a song about fleeting summer love; it’s about an intense emotional connection that, despite best efforts, ends in sorrow.

Curious about how the verses further unravel the pain and resilience in loving? Keep reading. We’re about to journey through the highs and lows of emotion as expressed in this iconic song.


“It’s a Heartache” Lyrics Meaning

From the onset, Bonnie Tyler sets a tone of melancholy. “It’s a heartache, Nothing but a heartache, Hits you when it’s too late, Hits you when you’re down” – these lines symbolize the shock and surprise one feels when heartbreak strikes. Often, heartbreak comes when least expected, amplifying the pain.

The mention of “It’s a fool’s game, Standing in the cold rain, Feeling like a clown” indicates the foolishness one feels in hindsight. The “cold rain” is symbolic of the harsh reality and the raw emotions faced, making one feel exposed and vulnerable.

The lyrics “Love him ’til your arms break, Then he lets you down” are particularly poignant. They reflect an intense commitment and love given to someone, only to be met with disappointment.

Bonnie further emphasizes the unfairness of one-sided love with “It ain’t right with love to share, When you find he doesn’t care for you.” It brings forth the dilemma many face – the unequal balance of affection, where one gives more than they receive.

The recurring theme of the song revolves around the relentless, sometimes naive nature of love. The act of loving, even when it’s met with indifference or betrayal, can be both a blessing and a curse.

“It ain’t wise to need someone, As much as I depended on you” – This line is particularly heartbreaking. It speaks to the dangers of becoming overly reliant emotionally on someone who doesn’t reciprocate that same depth of feeling.

The Story Behind “It’s a Heartache”

Bonnie Tyler’s “It’s a Heartache” has become an anthem for anyone who has loved and lost. However, Bonnie Tyler was not the original writer. The song was crafted by Ronnie Scott and Steve Wolfe. While it may be tempting to assume that these writers drew from personal experiences of heartbreak and love gone wrong, the process behind songwriting can often be more complex and nuanced.

Ronnie Scott and Steve Wolfe, who also happened to be Tyler’s managers at the time, wrote the song specifically for Tyler’s husky and distinctive voice. They aimed to craft a ballad that showcased her vocal strengths and could resonate with a broad audience. They succeeded. The raw emotion Tyler brought to the song made it relatable to countless listeners across the globe, turning it into an instant classic.

Though the exact inspirations behind the lyrics remain somewhat private to the writers, it’s evident that they tapped into universal feelings of longing, love, disappointment, and vulnerability. Drawing from general experiences and emotions that almost everyone has felt at some point in their lives, they created a song that transcends personal anecdotes and speaks to the collective human experience of heartache.