I Monster – “Who Is She ?” Lyrics Meaning

Photo of author
Written By Joanna Landrum

Joanna holds a BSc in English Literature and uses her expertise in literary analysis to uncover the deeper meaning of her favorite songs.

“I Monster’s ‘Who Is She?’ is an enigmatic ballad of longing, taking listeners on a journey of romantic mystique and timeless yearning. The song explores the concept of an elusive, possibly imaginary love interest, termed “Ayesha.” By painting vivid images of ‘a misty memory’ and ‘a haunting face,’ the song probes the nature of love and its borderline with illusion.

The songwriter beckons Ayesha, hoping she’ll answer across the ‘endless plain’ of time, demonstrating a profound quest for eternal love. The question ‘Who is she?’ isn’t just about identifying a person; it’s about understanding the depth of emotions and the ambiguous line between reality and dream.

Got your interest piqued? Dive in further to unravel the beauty hidden within the enigma that is ‘Who Is She?’.

“Who Is She?” Lyrics Meaning

We begin with the words “Oh, who is she? A misty memory, A haunting face, Is she a lost embrace?” This sets the stage for our narrative. The protagonist is ensnared by an enigmatic woman who might be a mere figment of his imagination. The phrase ‘a misty memory’ and ‘a haunting face’ suggests an otherworldly aura, hinting at the blurred boundaries between reality and imagination, the concrete and the ethereal.

In the lines “Am I in love with just a theme? Or is Ayesha just a dream?” we see the songwriter grappling with a compelling question. Is his love real, or is it a mere thematic construct of his mind? The use of ‘Ayesha,’ an Arabic name meaning ‘alive’ or ‘she who lives,’ can symbolize a desired yet elusive vitality in the protagonist’s life.

“I call her name, Across an endless plain, She’ll answer me, Wherever she may be,” further emphasizes the protagonist’s deep longing and belief in the transcendental power of his love. The ‘endless plain’ can be seen as a metaphor for the unfathomable expanse of time or the universe, intensifying the spiritual aspect of the song.

The repeated refrain of “Oh, who is she? A misty memory, A haunting face, Is she a lost embrace?” serves as a constant reminder of the protagonist’s quest for clarity, to understand the enigma that is Ayesha, while wrestling with his own perception of love and memory.

Finally, in the concluding lines, “Somewhere across the sea of time, A love immortal such as mine, Will come to me, Eternally, Immortal she, Return to me,” the protagonist asserts his conviction in the immortality and eternal nature of his love. He yearns for the return of his ‘immortal’ love, further mystifying the elusive ‘Ayesha.’

The Story Behind “Who Is She?”

As we attempt to decode the song, understanding the songwriter’s mindset is crucial. It seems that when “Who Is She?” was written, the songwriter was immersed in a mental landscape where the ephemeral and timeless coexisted. There appears to be a longing for connection, an eternal love that transcends the ordinary confines of reality.

The song gives us a glimpse into the universal human experience of love and longing, revealing that the songwriter, like us, has grappled with the blurred lines between reality and illusion, between a tangible lover and an idealized muse. It’s a testament to the enigmatic, complex nature of human emotions and how they can be both a source of profound inspiration and existential questioning.

“Who Is She?” also seems to stem from a state of introspection and self-reflection, a point in the songwriter’s life where questioning the nature and existence of love became paramount. The repeated line “Oh, who is she?” indicates an internal struggle with the concept of love, its authenticity, and its illusion.

In writing this song, the songwriter might have been coping with a deep sense of longing, or perhaps, trying to understand an emotion or a memory that couldn’t be entirely comprehended. The figure of Ayesha, the “misty memory” and “haunting face”, may represent an aspect of his past, a lost love, or even an idealized version of love that he yearns for.

Moreover, the use of the phrase “across the sea of time” reflects a state of mind that’s reconciling with the transient nature of human life and relationships. It suggests a yearning for something everlasting, immortal, in stark contrast with the impermanent reality we inhabit.

Underneath its melodic cadence, “Who Is She?” carries a weighty exploration of love, memory, and time. It not only offers a romantic ballad to its listeners but also serves as a poignant reflection on the human condition, echoing our own questions about love, memory, longing, and the eternal.

While we might never fully know who Ayesha is to the songwriter, the beauty of “Who Is She?” lies in this ambiguity. It invites listeners to project their own experiences, emotions, and interpretations onto the song, thus resonating with us in our unique, personal ways. Whether Ayesha is a lost love, a dream, or an immortal muse, she symbolizes the universal human yearning for love that transcends the bounds of time and mortality. The song thus stands as a timeless testament to the depth and complexity of human emotions, immortalizing the songwriter’s journey and, by extension, our own.