Leonard Cohen’s “First We Take Manhattan” is a song brimming with cryptic poetry and profound meaning. At its core, it’s about rebellion and change. Cohen delves into the mindset of a character disillusioned with society, striving to alter the system from within. The lyrics convey a message of determination and a desire for a societal shift, with a hint of personal vendetta. Cohen, known for his deep and thoughtful songwriting, created this piece as an expression of frustration and the urge for revolution.
“First We Take Manhattan” is a journey through rebellion, love, and change. Let’s explore how Leonard Cohen turns simple lyrics into a profound narrative.
“First We Take Manhattan” Lyrics Meaning
“First We Take Manhattan” starts with a declaration of rebellion against boredom and conformity: “They sentenced me to 20 years of boredom/For trying to change the system from within”. This sets the tone for the entire song – a battle against the status quo.
Cohen then speaks of coming to “reward” those who sentenced him, hinting at a reversal of roles or power. The refrain, “First we take Manhattan, then we take Berlin,” symbolizes a strategic, methodical plan for change, possibly in the realms of culture or ideology.
The song’s narrative weaves through themes of guidance, destiny, and rebellion. “A signal in the heavens guides me” suggests a divine or higher purpose, while the “birthmark on my skin” could symbolize a predestined role in life. The “beauty of our weapons” line is particularly intriguing, possibly metaphorical for the tools of change, be it words, art, or ideas.
Love and personal relationships intermingle with these themes of rebellion. “I’d really like to live beside you, baby” shows a softer, more intimate side, juxtaposed against the backdrop of societal change. This duality is poignant, highlighting the personal within the political.
Cohen’s disdain for superficiality surfaces in lines critiquing the fashion and drug industries. The reference to his sister adds a personal, perhaps painful element to his critique, making his rebellion more relatable and grounded in reality.
The song closes with a reflection on the past and a wounded yet resilient spirit: “Well, it’s Father’s Day, and everybody’s wounded.” This line encapsulates the collective pain and struggle, tying back to the overarching theme of change and revolution.
The Story Behind “First We Take Manhattan”
When Leonard Cohen wrote “First We Take Manhattan”, he was in a state of artistic resurgence and personal reflection. Cohen, often a contemplative and introspective songwriter, was looking at the world around him with a critical eye. The song was penned during a period when Cohen deeply questioned the societal norms and values that define our lives.
His approach to songwriting was always more poetic than literal, and this song is no exception. The lyrics are not just words but are a canvas where Cohen painted his thoughts on rebellion, love, societal flaws, and personal struggles. The song reflects his disenchantment with the superficial aspects of society, especially the fashion and music industries, and his empathy for personal suffering, as seen in the reference to his sister.
Cohen’s state of mind during this time was one of introspection and revolution. He was not just a songwriter but a philosopher, delving into the complexities of human emotions and societal structures. “First We Take Manhattan” is a culmination of these thoughts, a poetic manifesto that calls for change, both within and without.
The song remains a powerful testament to Cohen’s genius, a blend of personal narrative and universal themes, making it as relevant today as it was when it was first penned. It’s not just a song but a reflection of a profound artist at a pivotal moment in his career.