​The Lumineers – “Ophelia” Lyrics Meaning

Photo of author
Written By Joanna Landrum

Joanna holds a BSc in English Literature and uses her expertise in literary analysis to uncover the deeper meaning of her favorite songs.

“Ophelia” is a haunting exploration of love and loss, interwoven with a sense of nostalgia and regret. It delves into the complexities of a relationship, capturing the intensity of feelings and the pain of unrequited love. The lyrics paint a picture of someone who’s deeply affected by a past relationship with Ophelia, symbolizing an unattainable love or a lost opportunity. The songwriter seems to be expressing the turmoil of holding onto feelings for someone who doesn’t reciprocate them and the struggle of moving on. This song, rich in emotional depth, mirrors personal experiences, offering a message about the dangers of falling too deeply in love and the challenges of letting go.

Stick around to unravel the layers of this mesmerizing song and discover what truly lies beneath its poetic verses.


“Ophelia” Lyrics Meaning

The Lumineers’ “Ophelia” starts with a reflective tone, “I, I, when I was younger, I, I, should have known better”. This immediately sets the stage for a journey of self-realization and regret. The protagonist acknowledges past mistakes and a lack of foresight in his youth, suggesting a relationship that perhaps started too early or was too intense for his younger self to handle.

As the song progresses, “And I can’t feel no remorse, And you don’t feel nothing back”, we dive into the heart of unreciprocated feelings. It’s a powerful expression of emotional disconnect, highlighting the protagonist’s struggle with unreturned love and the emotional numbness that follows.

Then comes the chorus, “Oh, Ophelia, You’ve been on my mind girl since the flood”. Ophelia, a name rich in literary history, represents an idealized figure who’s been a constant presence in his thoughts. The reference to “the flood” could symbolize a tumultuous period in his life, marking a turning point in his emotional landscape.

The lines “I, I, got a new girlfriend, She feels like he’s on top” and “I, I, got a little paycheck, You got big plans and you gotta move” contrast the protagonist’s current life with his past. Despite new relationships and successes, he can’t escape the shadow of Ophelia. This ongoing comparison to the past suggests a deep-rooted attachment and a sense of what could have been.

The song concludes with a bittersweet acceptance, “Honey, I love you, that’s all she wrote”. It’s a resignation to the unchangeable nature of his feelings, accepting that some loves stay with us forever, even if they’re not meant to be.

The Story Behind “Ophelia”

“Ophelia” captures the essence of a person grappling with the residues of a past love. The choice of the name “Ophelia” is particularly poignant, possibly alluding to the tragic Shakespearean character who embodies innocence and the devastating effects of unrequited love. This parallel suggests that the songwriter might be reflecting on an intense and perhaps destructive relationship, much like the fate of Shakespeare’s Ophelia.

The lyrics, “I, I, when I was younger, I, I, should have known better,” indicate a sense of regret and a wish to have handled things differently. It’s a common sentiment as one grows older, looking back at past relationships through a lens of wisdom and often, a tinge of regret. The contrasting images of his current life and the unshakable memory of Ophelia paint a picture of a person who has moved on in life but is still haunted by what was left unresolved. This could reflect the songwriter’s own journey through different stages of life and love, acknowledging that some people leave a lasting imprint, regardless of where life takes us.

In conclusion, the story behind “Ophelia” is not just about a lost love; it’s about growth, understanding, and the enduring impact of our past. It’s a testament to the songwriter’s state of mind during its creation – a blend of nostalgia, wisdom, and a bittersweet acceptance of life’s intricate emotional tapestry.